Home Shop Cart Account

Wedding
Stationery
Greeting Cards
Gifts
Paper & Crafts
Wrap & Party
Personalized
Collections & Sale

Christmas-Themed Gifts

Christmas-Themed Gifts

Subscribe to our newsletter for exclusive offers, new arrivals, and style inspiration.

Shop

All Products
New Arrivals
Sale

Company

Shipping Info
FAQ
Contact Us

About

About Us
Returns
Privacy

© 2026 Paper Source. All rights reserved.

Christmas-Themed Gifts | Paper Source

...

-65%

Highland Frost Candle

$34.99

$12.25

Balsam & Cedar Glass Ornament Candle

$31.99

-65%

Wreath Light Up Glasses

$12.99

$4.55

-65%

Santa and Elf Glasses, Assorted

$10.99

$3.85

-65%

LEGO Iconic Christmas Tree 40573

$44.99

$15.75

LEGO Icons Poinsettia 10370

$49.99

Never Been Happier Ornament

$16.50

NOSTALGIC TREE LIGHT UP ORNAMENT

$19.99

Jolly Jingles Radio Ornament - Red

$19.99

Tapple by NPD Partnership Ltd. (NPD Toys)

$21.99

-65%

Hues and Cues by Scott Brady

$25.99

$9.10

-65%

Nostalgic Lidded Tree Candle

$19.99

$7.00